Lokpal Bill Fiasco!

Our much awaited Lokpal Bill has slipped into coma at the stroke of midnight and many win freedom from the uneasy thought that much talked-about antigraft Bill would disturb them in near future.More than forty years have taken for the passage of the Bill in Lok Sabha and it might take another forty years or more to be passed in Rajya Sabha.It's true unless prodded by Anna Hazare the bill would not have even been placed in LS for consideration.Anna might rather find solace in it instead of grudging the tragic fate of the BILL.. Initially Team Anna's antigraft campaign received unprecedented support from across the country and it indicated in no uncertain terms the popular contempt against corruptions.But people too got fed up with passage of time as the relation between Team Anna and UPA govt increasingly deteriorated and ultimately perhaps they lost much of their interest in Lokpal issue as was evident in thin attendance of people at Anna's Fast venue at Mumbai.Now politicians are as usual at blame game one political party passing the buck to anther for Lokpal BIll fiasco.What was, in fact, wanting in the entire issue was the sincerity of the politicians cutting across party lines to pass the Bill.It's extremely unfortunate, in deed.

AMRI Hospital Tragedy

The blood curdling scenes of people jumping to death from Stephen court building engulfed in devastating fire in a desperate bid to save their lives are still fresh in our memory.Then we thought administration and people as well would take lesson from this macabre story and try to ensure such an incident does never occur.But we were totally wrong and AMRI Hospital tragedy has proved it in no uncertain terms.Instances of death toll of such magnitude in hospital fire are quite rare even in other parts of the world.Here at AMRI patients were not burnt to death,they were suffocated to death in smoke that fire generated.More than ninety lives were lost.Patients who were critically ill or orthopedically handicapped fell easy prey to fire.Fire reportedly broke out at the basement where combustible and inflammable subtances were allegedly stored.Smoke bellowed up through the ducts of centrally air-conditioning system and filled the rooms of the patients. Glass pans of the building were so tightly sealed accumulated smoke could not go out.Nor was there any device to let out the gas in case of emergency.Fire or smoke alarm did not buzz either.

Other private or govt hospitals in the city are reportedly no better than AMRI so far as the safety and security are concerned.Most of them flout fire safety norms, let alone provide proper arrangement to evacuate the patients in case the situation so demands.Conditions of govt hospitals are even worse.In fact, these hospitals too deserve the cancellation of permission for being run in this abjectly indifferent way.One wonders how the men in administration have turned a blind eye to the blatant and criminal lapses perptrated by the hospital authorities for years together.So they too are no less guilty than the callous managerial staff of AMRI for this most painful human tragedy.

What's most unfotunate and certain too is the flurry of activities now being shown by the administration to ensure that such a tragedy is not ever repeated in future would gradually die down and things would be back to square one till another such incident occures that would awaken the adminstration to embark upon some knee jerk measures again.

Striking Exam Date!

Citu,one of the sponsors of Industrial strike on Feb 28, 2012 have locked horn with the Education ministry of the state over the date of strike.On this very date 11 lacs students would appear at the history paper of Madhyamic examinations.Education minister has declared that the date of examination would not be changed in view of the strike.He argues date was fixed one year back and obviously much before the date of Industrial strike was announced.So trade unions should have taken into consideration the concerned date while fixing the date of strike.Citu counter argues that as it is an All India strike whichever date is chosen it'd affect examinations in some state or other.Both sides appear to be right in their arguments but if they stick to their stand it is the students who would be worst sufferers.If the examination is held on the day of strike students would be in sheer trouble for transport problem.So it's wise for the Board of Secondary education not to make it a prestige issue and shift the date of exam at least in the interest of students and guardians.Delhi Board is reportedly considering to shift the dates of its exams scheduled to be held on the day of strike.In fact,it's nothing new to change the date of examinations in view of strikes or bandhs.
--

Off the hook!

Anti-hooking operation at Magrahat:
Govt has done nothing wrong in making an attempt to stop theft of electricity through hooking at Magrahat.People can't claim the right to hooking as they have not been given electrical connection by WBSEB as yet even after depositing necessary money.Theft is theft, it can't be legalised under any circumstances.The law abiding customers have to pay for this theft of electricty.It also results in huge revenue loss of the state.In fact, widespread hooking which is in many cases deliberately overlooked for some reason or other has made it, as if ,the fundamental right of the hookers..So any move to stop this malpractice would not go unopposed.Administration should tread cautiously and tactfully to tackle the issue.Perhaps at Magrahat authorities made no proper ground work before taking on the offenders or could not handle the situation properly because of lack of coordination.Whatever might be the cause two precious lives were lost.

Now blame game has started.CM has as usual smelled conspiracy in the matter.However, she's ashamed of such a sad incident.She's blamed police for firing and also for their lack of skill to disperse mob without killing any one.She regrets she's to employ trigger happy police of the Left regime.She's also pleaded she was posted on the incidence the following day, although the home secretary claimed he knew it on the day of occurrence.She has, however, ordered to stop anti-hooking operation obviously much to the delight of the hookers.Now she's making her best to get off the hook.The opposition is as usual trying their best to cash in on this situation as she did when in opposition.

Incidentally,thanks to present govt's power policy vis-a-vis power generation by installing new power plants and determination not to enhance power tariff to increase revenue to keep the present power plants running properly , there'd be no need to carry out Operation Hookers soon as electricty would be a rare entity.

--

Kisanji's Death

Any death is unfortunate.Similar is Kisanji's although he has been cause of deaths for many.He believed in ideology 'political power comes out of the barrel of the gun'.It precisely boils down to the concept that state power could be captured through violence only.How far this idea is relevant in a country like ours is a different story.But we've seen the poorest of the poor falling victims to such an ideology in Jangalmahal.Many innocent people have been mercilessly killed.People are terrorized at gun point to obey the diktat of his party.Incidentally, the Maoists were losing their support base among people of Jangalmahal primarily because of the promises galore of developments and job opportunities made by the new govt, however, knowing fully well that such promises are difficult to implement for lack of funds.Any way, people believed govt and helped the joint forces with tips about the whereabouts of Kisjenji.However, it's a surmise and might sound too naive..

Another theory envisages that Maoists in Jangalmahal have got disorganized because of internal dissension.Of late, surrender of Maoist leaders lend credence to such an assumption.What's more,the leaders who've surrendered to govt were in contact with police for a long time and might be a source of information for cops.

There's an old saying: one murder makes a villain and thousand a hero.So Kisanji's a hero to many.Association for Protection of Democratic Rights(APDR) has claimed Kisanji has not been killed in encounter.He has been instead first arrested and then murdered.Many people have,however, shared this view.They think circumstantial evidences apparently suggest such probability.So APDR have claimed proper enquiry in this case.Kisanji;s mother,a 86 yr.old cancer patient, has decided to file a suit claiming that her son was murdered in cold blood by police at Calcutta High court.

Now it's true Maoists' movement at Jangalmahal has received a jolt for Kisanj's death.On the other hand joint forces have received a shot in the arm for this hard earned success.

APDR's Contention

APDR's( Association for Protection of Democratic Rights) vehement protest against the present govt's refusal to permit the organisation to hold rally at Metro Channel on the ground that the venue has been preoccupied seems irrational.Nor our revered writer Mahasweta Devi's contention that the present govt is a fascist one does sound very rational.Perhaps in a fit of rage she uttered such a strong word to mean the authoritarian attitude of the present govt.What's more, CM should have also shown more restraint while reacting to such an allegation either.Situation has gone to such a pass probably because APDR consider the story of preoccupation of the venue is cooked to desist them from holding rally at Metro Channel to discuss issues like withdrawal of joint forces from Jangalmahal and unconditional release of prisoners that would embarrass govt as Mamata Banerjee herself made such demands when in opposition.Incidentally,govt offered two other alternate sites for APDR's rally.

However,if APDR's contention that govt has deliberately not allowed to hold meeting at Metro Channel is true, the trend is obviously ominous.In democracy every individual should be allowed to speak his or her mind even if it's not acceptable to govt.In the event it's not done one might have the premonition that an authoritarian rule is staring us in the face.

In Jest Only!

(1)Pass-fail
Son:Dad, they've decided to do away with pass-fail system up to class VIII in schools.
Dad:Yes, son.It makes no sense to keep both the systems.
Son:Why dad?
Dad:See fail means not to pass.So they keep only one system-pass.

(2)Wounds of love
Son:Dad,it's hardly six months since TMC-Cong govt was formed when Cong complains of assault on them by TMC.
Dad:These are only wounds of love for cong, my son.

(3)Joint forces
Son: Dad,whom does Didi refer to when she says 'joint forces' in Jangalmahal?
Dad: Simple! CPI(M) and Maoists combine.

Didi's Performance

Didi's an inexhaustible storehouse of energy.Hers is a dynamic personality both in figurative as well as in literal senses.She's always on the move untiringly traversing length and breath of the state.She's always after bringing about change almost in every walk of life-cultural, social and administrative.Well being of the state seems to be be-all and end -all of her life.In fact she single handedly rules the state.Hers is the last word in every matter.In her govt no minister dares take a decision even in a petty matter without consulting her.Nor do they ever fail to mention her as ' Our leader Mamata Banerjee so desires' in any public utterance .Such an unwavering allegiance to the leader is uniquely rare in any party.So she stands accountable to the successes and failures of her govt.

In such a short span of time since she assumed office as Chief minister it's difficult to pronounce upon the performances of her govt.However,she claims success in many spheres in record time.Unfortunately it's difficult to agree with her on this count.As for instance, in hills though peace is now prevailing but the recent maneuvering of GJM to form GATA in collusion with some leaders of Adibasi Bikas Parisad even after passing of GTA Bill lends. support to speculation that GJM would relaunch their movement for a separate Gorkha land in near future.At present all political parties in hills boycott the upcoming civic polls alleging that democratic atmosphere is not prevailing in hills due to autocratic attitude of GJM.

Next, for situation in Jangalmahal the less said the better.Didi's strategy to bring peace in Jangalmahal by developmental activities is unlikely to yield results.Nor has proved the peace talk with the Maoists through interlocutors a wee bit fruitful..Maoists rather non-nonchalantly take to their killing spree as usual.Now have they more consolidated than ever before taking advantage of Didi's decision to put the activities of Joint forces partially on hold.In fact, Jangalmahal is fuming.

The return of Singur land to the unwilling farmers,Didi's pre-electoral promise, is now locked in litigation.No body knows when the legal battle will end and the unwilling farmers would get back their cherished land.

Didi could not make public the so called 'secret treaty' with Tatas made by LF govt for legal
hurdle.It was also Didi's pre-electoral assurance.

Truely speaking Didi's yet to provide us good governance.In fact, her govt is a prisoner of indecision rather.It takes decisions and later rescinds it itself.For example.for admission to schools it initially did away with lottery system as introduced by the earlier govt as 'it might inculcate a sense of gambling in young minds'.But it's now revised its earlier decision and come back to square one.To remove Dalatantra(political hegemony) from arena of education the the new ordinance from Education Ministry pruning the representation of students, non teaching staff etc from senates and syndicates of universities of the state has triggered debate in academic circle.

Didi likes to change the old order and brings in some thing new.This dynamism is really commendable.But before changing the old system some home work should be done.In fact,justice hurried is justice buried

Didi now more depends on administrative heads like BDOs,SDOs DMs rather than on the elected members of Panchayet for developmental activities in districts.Her move is likely to destablise our Panchayet system.So all political parties including her ally Congress vehemently oppose such activities.

Health services are now in total disarray.Admittedly, they were no better earlier.Crib deaths are recently so rampant parents fear to visit hospitals.But govt each time claims such deaths are nothing but normal.True,hospitals are not always to blame.They can't bear the brunt of patients.Human negligence is also a factor too.So total overhauling of health services are extremely necessary.Didi's encumbered with so many responsibilities that she can hardly do justice to them.So people truly demand a full time Health minister.Would Didi provide one?

I

Taking people for a ride?

Mamata Banerjee's stance on petrol price rise:

Now Didi is put on the spot over petrol price hike.In last twelve months petrol price has increased as many as eleven times, perhaps a record till date.Hike in petrol price boosts up prices of other essential commodities also which are incidentally already too high.As Trinommol Congress is one of the biggest allies of coalition govt at center,it should share the responsibility of fuel price rice.But Didi does not like to do so as it might affect her popularity and CMP would take this opportunity to score a point over her.So she's gone in for vociferously defending her position by vehemently protesting against such rise in petrol price. She's also pleaded that her party was kept in the dark in this matter.She's even threatened to pull out of UPA in protest but refrained from taking such a drastic action because it'd topple the govt.

In fact, last year UPA govt took the decision in its cabinet meeting to decontrol the prices of fuels and left it to market to determine them. Didi was then Railway minister. For some reason or other she skipped the meeting. She, however, didn't later on object to the decision taken by the union cabinet either.So Didi was legally a party to the decision to decontrol the price of petrol.Now how could she claim petrol price has been hiked without taking her in confidence and threaten to part with UPA govt on this count?Isn't it an attempt to take people for a ride?

Scanning Media

The Press Council Chairman's remark about the journalists sound too
harsh and too generalised.Almost all professions are manned by
mediocre people- the talents are always few and far between.All
professions have sincere and honest people and at the same time very
dishonest and insincere guys.So our fourth estate is no exception.
Journalism is in fact a very noble profession and it's a very
challenging and reponsible job too.

Unfortunately journalism has lost much of its sheen over the years.Now
it has become like any other profession.Both print and electronic
media, definitely not all, have ceased to behave responsibly and
honestly.Media should be objective in dessemination of news without
indulging in subjective assessment.In most cases views dominate
news.For print media there is leader page to analyse the story in
their own way.But still the correspondent pronounces his views while
catering the news.Some times the same story is telecast or printed in
different ways in different TV channels or news papers.It confuses the
readers or viewers rather than bring home to them what has exactly
happened.Often stories are tailored to suit the convenience of the
media house.

Sadly,media,particularly the regional ones,are now more or less politically
polarised- a section takes the onus of defending the ruling party,
sometimes brazenly and others indulge in crticising the govt at the
drop of a hat.They hardly take a neutral and dispassionate stance that
they're supposed to do.So press is more often than not accused of
partisan outlook.Press Council Chairman's view that electronic media
should be brought under the ambit of Press Council perhaps deserve
support from all corners.

Once paid news was unheard-of a phrase but now it's so common that
sensible media people are scared of it.Nevertheless there is no
dearth of honest, fearless and dedicated journalists who make no
compromise with truth and never fall short of calling spade a spade.
Hats off to them.

Yagna for Industrialisation!

Bengal has penchant for making Yagna.They make this ritual almost at the drop of a hat.The occasion may include Sourav's inclusion in Indian team or winning a para football match.So it's no wonder that Yagna will be made for state's development and industrialization.But what wonders one is such a Yagna is being made by industrialists themselves.The Yagna will continue for as many as nine days and it's attended by no lesser mortal than the Agricultural minister Arup Ray as govt representative..But why do the captains of industries need to seek the favour of God through perforemance of Yagna?Do they feel such Yogna would make the present govt more industry friendly to negotiate the present hurdles( for example govt's land policy) in the way of industrialization which they pointed out in the recent meet with CM.Do they think Yogna may help refurbish the tarnished image of the state following Singur automobile project fiasco?Govt and Tatas are now locked in legal battles over the project site and it rekindles the memory of Tatas leaving the state after near completion of their work for Nano factory.It might adversely affect the prospect of industrialization in the state.However,such Yognas do not in any way send a good message across the country.On the contrary it reveals the hapless plight of the new govt so far as the industrialization is concerned..

What's very interesting is on the very Ist day of Yanga Mamata Banerjee declared eight investment proposals totaling as much as 20,000 crores of rupees.Who says it can't be the instant effect of Yagna?

Damage Control!

Ms.Kiran Bedi refunds Excess fare to her hosts:
Unless it was brought to light by Indian Express it could not be known that Kiran Bedi, one of the most active and eloquent members of Anna Team, charged her hosts more travel expenses than she actually paid on the occasion of attending functions organised by them.Ms. Bedi is entitled to concessional fare for her being a gallant award winner.What's more,she sometimes claimed business class fare though she traveled in economy class.She,however, initially justified drawing extra fare from her hosts claiming she paid the extra money to her NGO.But she drew flak from all corners and has now decided to refund the extra fare to her hosts.It's a pity she's fighting against corruptions but indulging in corruptions herself.Such incidents would not only tarnish her image but also do immense harm to anti-graft campaign being spear headed by Anna.Thousands of people cutting across castes, creeds and political complexions who extented unstinted and unprecedented support to Anna in his crusade against corruptions would feel betrayed.It may be noted there're evil foces lurking around to sabotage the anti corruption move to perpetuate corruptions.Such incidents would only help serve their purpose.

In Jest Only!

(1)Simply illusion
Son:Dad,the other day Didi said there were no Maoists in Jangalmahal.
Dad:Yes, my boy.
Son :But now she says Maoists are there.
Dad: It was her political illusion, my son.

(2)Empty vessel
Son: Didi says the state's coffer is empty.
Dad: Yes,Didi claims so,my boy.
Son: Then why does she lavishly offer sops where-ever she visits?
Dad: Perhaps it's because empty vessels sound much, my boy.

(3)War and peace!
Son: Were Tolstoy alive today,he could write War and Peace in totally different way.
Dad: Why, my son.
Son: See dad, while joint forces and the Maoists are engaged in gun battle at Jangalmahal
peace talk is going on at Writers.
Dad:There's nothing unfair in peace and war, my boy!

Tread cautiously!

Allegation against Kiran Bedi:
It's shocking the members of Anna team are getting involved in controversy.Team is fighting against corruption, so people expect their honesty and integrity should be beyond question.Recent allegation against Kiran Bedi, the most important and influential member of Anna team is really unfortunate.She's alleged to have drawn full fare from organisations who invite her to grace any function organised by them though she herself enjoys concession in fare for her gallantry award.Bedi however admits to this practice but justifies that she does no wrong as she donate the excess money thus drawn to her NGO.What's interesting organisers don't reportedly know that she draws more fare than what she actually pays.Taken for granted that she's personally honest but the way she raises funds for her NGO can't be justified though she might argue that end justifies the means.It might belittle her position in the estimation of public and generate misconception and misgivings.What's most worrying, Anna's war against corruptions might get a jolt for such activities.It must be noted evil forces are there to undo and upset what has so far been achieved in anti-graft campaign.

Jangalmahal Revisited

Didi's double speak is likely to throw spanner in the peace process that is scheduled to ensue if both the Maoist and the govt abjure arms and for that matter in the developmental activities those Didi has promised.When in opposition Didi posed not to believe there were the Maoists in Jangal mahal and insisted on withdrawal of the joint forces.She also promised to free people who were behind the bar for allegedly performing Maoist activities.In her opinion CPM masquerade as Maoists and make wanton killings in jangal mahal.So she did hardly denounce these killings as vociferously as she does now when her party activists are murdered by Maoists.Maoists in fact expected she'd keep her promises when she'd be in power.

It's not however true that Didi's done nothing for the Maoists when she's come to power. She's not that ungrateful.During LF regime Maoists were almost cornered because of sustained operation of the joint forces.Didi came to power and put on hold the joint force's operation for as many as 4 months perhaps to allow them to regroup ,strengthen and spread their tentacles over larger domain.Now Maosts make their presence felt even in Midnapore town too..That apart, in the name of opening dialogue with Maoists Didi is giving them further time to set their house properly in order.It's well known that good day will never come when the Maoists and Didi would start dialogue across the table.Didi has allowed the Maoists to buy time ignoring the report of the Central intelligence.

However,Didi's officially changed her stance and admit that Maoists are a veritable problem in Jangalmahal.Didi now call them Jangal Mafia and supari killers.She's given them seven days' time to abjure arms and sit across the negotiation table.The Maoist didn't dither to react promptly.They refused talk unless joint forces are withdrawn and and those who're in jail are unconditionally released.Such a tough stance taken by Didi overnight has hurt the supporters and sympathisers of the Maoists and put the self appointed interlocutors to start dialogue between the Maoists and the govt are put on the spot.Ensconced in power Didi has radically changed her attitude to the Maoists and it's shocked and surprised many.Isn't it, in fact , the fall out of Didi's doublespeak?

An Ugly Attack!

The sight of Supreme Court lawyer and a social activist Prasant bhusan being brutally roughed up by two youths in his SC chamber beamed on TV screen is utterly shocking and took many by surprise.It's unimaginable that such an ugly and barbaric act could happen in a civilized society.It's reportedly the fall out of Mr Bhusan's recent remark on Kashmir.He called for referendum to resolve Kashmir issue.It's absolutely his view and one may not agree with it.In a democracy every body can speak his mind and our democracy is well founded.It has braced many rough weathers and has emerged stronger in the process.Tolerance and to pay heed to other people's view is the basic tenet of our democracy.Some time back social activist and Pulitzer prize winner Arundhati Roy commented Kashmir was not the integral part of India.Her remark created ripple.Some people denounced it and some welcomed it too.Debate on her comment continued for long and has now subsided.Prasant Bhusan's comment too has triggered a debate that would die down in days to come.This question of referendum regarding Kashmir was often heard probably during Nehru's regime and Bhusan has revived it after so many years.

In fact, there's no room for intolerance in democracy.So the organisations those inculcate intolerance and violence in their members should be closely monitored and if necessary they should be banned. The youths who gave vent to their pent up rage on Bhusan for a remark that did offend them should be taught a hard lesson so that they'd not ever venture to repeat the same.

Assessing Private Engineering Colleges

Perhaps now we've more private engineering colleges than we require.The way these colleges have mushroomed almost overnight it's not expected they would impart quality education.Nor has the ministry of education ever assessed their standard.What the administration has done is routine inspection which provides no idea regarding the standard of students or the quality of education these institutes can afford.A standard engineering college must have duly qualified faculty,proper infrastructure that includes well equipped laboratories and libraries rich in reference and text books.Above all it needs good quality students whose performance in examinations and later in service life earn any institute a good name.

Govt tries to assuage the quality of private engineering colleges by comparing the marks a student gets in internal assessment done by the college and in the test conducted by the expert committee of WBUT.If the difference between these marks is quite high the concerned college must explain it.In fact it's no way to judge the quality of the college, rather it's means to assess its honesty and integrity.In fact almost all colleges award higher marks in internal assessment.However,by this process the marks obtained by the student in expert Committee's test might have reflection on the quality of this student and for that matter the quality of the college.

What's most worrying is save a few private colleges the rest get average students who've ranked low in JEE or even those who've not ranked at all but have passed XIISc exam with only 45% marks each in Physics, Chemistry and Mathematics.If qualifying marks for admission to an engineering college is kept such abjectly low how could one expect the standard of engineering education would be satisfactorily high in private engineering colleges?

The teaching and non teaching staff of most of the Pvt engineering colleges are not properly paid.Very few colleges have offered new pay scale to the staff.So good students hardly opt for teaching assignment in these engineering colleges. While assessing the standard of tech colleges the proposed committee should look into the grievances of the teaching and non teaching staff of pvt colleges..
--

Poll results and Performance!

It's the best of times for Didi and worst of times for the Left Front.By election results strongly corroborate the above view.It's no denying the fact that anti Left wind is blowing hard, if not harder.Hang-over of anti incumbency factor is prevailing strong.At Basirhat last time CPM won by a slender margin of some three thousand odd votes.This time TMC has increased the margin of win almost tenfold. Didi was sure of win in this seat as this time Cong-TMC alliance was strong enough to allay the fear of division of votes in favour of CPM, that occured on the last occasion due to lack of understanding between these two parties.Nevertheless Didi couldn't think margin will be this much. Nor could she imagine she'd win by such staggeringly high percentage of votes in her own constituency as vote polled was unexpectedly low.Rather she was perhaps trying to analyse why people became so much disinterested in exercising their franchise in short span of four months.Poll pundits too felt anxious if Didi could exceed the earlier margin of win by her party colleague at least in terms of percentage votes polled in her favour.Belying all speculation Didi has proved without a whisker of doubt that her popularity has not a wee bit waned.

The results of by elections amply prove people still repose faith in Didi and believe she'd deliver goods if given sufficient time.But are these results popular endorsement of what Didi has done in last four months?Answer is perhaps 'no'.But why?People believe Didi's a symbol of change,she can change what was wrong in LF regime.She can award good governance and establish rule of law that was lacking at least towards the end of LF rule.People expect she'd establish Ganatantra (democracy) in place of Dalatantra allegedly pampered by the earlier govt.Unfortunately none of the above expectations to mention only a few, have come true.The law and order situation has not at all improved as incidences of inter party clashes, thefts, dacoities, extortion, murders have not waned a little.Dalatantra rules the roost in most instances as in LF regime.The health services are not in shape either.The public hospitals are in disarray as usual though Didi initially tried to set them right by her surprise visits.Condition of roads are awfully bad in most places without any sign of improvement.In reality,people feel no perceptible change in last four months.

Didi ,however, boast the advent of peace in hills following treaty with GJM after long disturbance and unrest.Experts, however say peace has been rather purchased for the time being paving the way for greater movement for separate state of Gorkhaland in near future as in the treaty it's been incorporated that GJM do not part with their demand for separate Gorkha land.

When in opposition Didi did not admit of presence of Maoists in Jungalmahal and demanded withdrawal of joint forces.But after coming to power she's made a u-turn and admit Maoists are veritable problem in Jangalmahal.Of course, initially she put the joint forces partially on hold to start dialogue with the Maoists.It, however,helped the Maoists to regroup and gain momentum to strike the administration with renewed vengeance.In fact, they've spread their organisation over wider domain holding threat to urban areas in Bankura and Midnapore.

Didi's new land policy that requires procurement of 100% land by the industrialists themselves poses a deterent to industrialisation.In our state where land is fragmented it's diffult to procure land without govt particpating in the process.It would simply help the land sharks to make huge fortunes.

In fine, to keep electoral promise to return 400 acre of land to the unwilling farmers of Singur Didi went to the extent of making new land act specifically for Singur and fought legal battle with Tatas and won it too.But the entire story is the fall-out of a tragic episode that a automobile factory that could change the fate of Singur people could not see the light of the day even after near completion of project work for making this '400 acre of land', a prestige issue ,which is now reportedly estimated much less than what was claimed.

Ban on plastic bags!

Use of plastic bags(40 microns or less in thickness) are banned in our state but in most places the ban is honoured more in defiance than in compliance .Shop keepers blame the customers for this fiasco.Customers insist on providing them plastic bags to carry the goods they purchase.In case the sellers refuse to oblige them they too refuse to buy goods from them(sellers) and go to other shops where carry bags are available.So the law abiding shopkeepers contend they lose customers in the process.The use of plastic bags can't be stopped unless all sellers refuse to provide carry bag to buyers.However, this is possible only when administration strictly enforce this ban by surprise visit at shops and awarding punishment to the offenders.The customers too should be fined in the event the person is found to carry goods in plastic bags.However,the best result can be obtained if manufacture of such bags are prohibited.

The innocent looking plastic bags can create havoc.They clog our sewerage system and can create even flood.They prohibit aeration of irrigation land affecting its fertility,They Kill thousands of animals each year as the animals ingest them considering as food.They make the environment dirty.It may be noted these bags are not biodegradable and remain undecomposed for years together.

It's true by enforcing law alone such problem can't be sorted out.Public awareness needs to be grown too in this regard. to enlist their support and cooperation in favour of the ban.Long habit of not carrying bags while going to market might initially make the buyers feel ill at ease but after a few days they will be accustomed to carry non plastic bags for marketing.
--

24 Ghanta an Ad Channel or News Channel?

To whom it may concern:
Dear Sir,
It's difficult to say if 24Ghanta is an ad channel or a news channel.Perhaps you telecast more ads than news or it's 50-50 in proportion.In fact, those who invest in ads hardly get their return as during long ad session the viewers switch over to other channels( at least I do it) where some programs are being telecast.What's more,quality of ads now a days have so deteriorated that they are not worth viewing.Ads are in most cases very silly and irritating.There're very few imaginative and innovative ads that could hold viewers on to the channel.Admittedly, sans ads it might be difficult for you to defray the expenses of running your channel and the falling standard of ads are not your fault either.But your seemingly the-more-the-merrier concept proves a trial of patience to the viewers.A day might come,I'm afraid,when the news items would be displayed in scrolls and ads in the rest of the screen all the time.

Paranoia?

Didi's otherwise fearless and fire brand but she seems to be suffering from paranoia.Yesterday the Kolkata bound aircraft which she was on board from Bagdogra after her visit to North Bengal and Sikkim following the devastating earth quake that claimed many valuable lives touched Dumdum airport 30 minutes late.The plane hovered in the sky for some time in the inclement weather for some technical reason.Didi fumed and complained that it was deliberately done to harass her.Later Mukul Ray who accompanied her in her tour lodged formal complaint with the air port authority who'd examine the matter,though they were surprised and shocked at such a complaint from no lesser mortal than CM. They claimed delay was totally unintentional as the plane had to hover in the sky as situation so demanded. They further claimed they didn't even know she was on board the plane.

During LF rule Didi often complained that govt was hatching conspiracy to kill her.Once a truck accidentally slipped before Didi's Convoy and she complained that it was an attempt on her life.The poor driver from Punjab had to pay a heavy price for a minor mistake.He was apprehended and put behind bar for couple of days.

Modi's Luxurious Fast

They say occasional fast is good for health.However, this good piece of advice is applicable to well fed or over-fed people and not to those who're half fed or compelled to go on fast most of the days.Narendra Modi's time bound luxury fast in cool ambiance of air conditioned venue is, of course, intenteded to improve his political health.Bitten by ambition and not by conscience Modi goes on fast in media glare to clear his desk for making it to national politics to stake his candidature for Primeminstership in the Loksabha polls in 2014.Admittedly, Modi has burnished his image for his developmental activities in Gujarat but Godhra riot has equally tarnished his image.In national politics Muslim vote bank is an important factor to reckon with.So Modi has now taken pro-Muslim stance referring to the need for extending educational facilities to Muslim and embarking upon progressive activities without any discrimination.Modi's fast is a desperate bid to shrug off the communal stink he has earned and send message to the Muslim community that he's now a changed man altogether.It's difficult to predict how much political dividend he'd earn from his much hyped luxurious fast.

Fixing Sites For Poltical Rallies!

Rallies,road blockades, bandhs are necessary evils in democracy.They're evils because they cause much inconveniences to general public and necessary because they are used to protest against injustice done to people in general or to a section of people.These weapons have been used or some times over used and misused since long normally by political parties.These forms of protest have become ,so to say, their birth rights. Hence any attempt to forfeit this right is an excercise in vain.Nor is it prudent to ban these programs in popular interest itself.Now what we need to do is make an endeavour to minimise the inconveniences caused to general people for rallies in particular.However, bandhs should be abjured as far as possible and might be used as the last resort only.

Left Front govt under the leadership of Buddha Bhattacherjee took initiative to address this problem.He earmarked a few places to make rallies to avoid traffic snarl-up in the city.A all party meet was called to this effect but the political parties could not reach a consensus.Incidentally,TMC boycotted the meet.Since then much water has flown down the Ganges.Mamata Banerjee made fast for days together at Metro channel to protest against the forcible acquisition of land from the farmers at Singur.She also staged dharna at Singur throwing traffic movement at Durgapur Express way totally out of the gear for as many as 14 days at a stretch..Political atmosphere was then intensely turbulent.Rallies and bandhs were almost regular features.They were mostly called by the opposition.Ruling parties too did not much lag behind.However,to cap it all TMC earned the dubious distinction of going on the rampage at the assembly house and there broke the costly furniture, those have archaic values too,ruthlessly to pieces.

Days have changed.TMC is now in power and the Left rule has ended after long 34 years.History repeats itself.Mamata Banejee is going to do what Buddhadev Bhattacherjee once tried to in LF regime but failed as referred to above.She's proposed to fix a few sites for political rallies so that people get at least a partial respite from traffic jam that puts them in immense hardship.She likes to prohibit rally at metro channel as it's at the center of the city.That apart she's also suggested to hold rallies preferably on Saturdays and Sundays.The proposals are no doubt good but unfortunately all party meet recently held yielded no result.A silver lining is the opposition now don't skip the meeting convened by the ruling parties.Political parties will meet again on this issue and let us hope for the best

Shortcomings of Didi's Draft Land Bill

On draft Land Bill of West Bengal govt:
So far as compensation to land losers in her land bill is concerned Didi has taken cue from the central counterpart.Proposed offer is uniquely good.But where will money come from to fulfil the commitment as the govt is cash trapped?Similar argument might be tagged with the offer of providing employment to the land losers.That apart, compensation at flat rate irrespective of quantum of land as suggested in the clause may not appear rational to the land owners.

The clause that asks the private companies to buy 100% land from the owners directly even for public purposes and govt would in no way participate in the process will certainly create more problems than it solves.Incidentally,this clause is applicable to P-P-P projects also.It's not possible for the industrialists to approach the land owners individually particularly in a state like ours where land is fragmented in innumerable small plots after land reform.So land sharks will rule the roost as seen in vedic village scandal.That apart, some land owners themselves might ask for exorbitantly high price or might be unwilling to sell out his/her plot for some reason or other.It will disturb contiguity and the buyer would have no choice but to abandon purchase of the tract of land on which a small factory or a big industry that could generate employments was to come up.In short the present clause is not industry friendly.There's another aspect too.As govt has no control on private purchase, a buyer might lure a farmer to give away his multi crop land and it'll affect our food production badly.So this clause need to be reviewed and govt in some way or other should participate in such land deal.

Another clause that needs reconsideration is the purchase of land by the govt for public purposes like laying of railway tracks, construction of hospitals , roads etc.Here the consent of 100% owners is a must.In practice it's not possible.For a tract of land some owners might be unwilling to give away their plots..In that case, govt will have to backtrack.So the general rule should be if majority(say 80% as in central bill) of the land owners agree to part with their land, whole land can be acquired.

--

Dissolution of Executive council

Mentor group vs.Executive Council:
It's a bad beginning for Presidency University.Little did Mamata Banerjee think when she initiated the move to create Mentor group for the better functioning of this university that it'd lock horn with the existing Executive Council(EC) on various issues instead of working in tandem.Both Mentor group and EC have eminent personalities as their members.EC is more powerful in the sense that it's executive power while the Mentor group is only an advisory body whose advice,however, is no binding on EC.In view of on- going conflict between the two bodies govt has decided to dissolve the present EC and form a new one inducting the present members of the Mentor group in it.What's interesting,Mentor group will also co-exist with EC with more or less the same members manning the two bodies.Now, what is the necessity of Mentor group if it's members common with those of EC?Even if the members of the mentor group are replaced by new members in future, is there any guarantee that both the bodies would work in unision without any difference of opinion as of now ?In fact,what's the harm if there's no Mentor group at all?Too many cooks just spoil the broth.

However, the saddest part of the story is the unceremonious dismissal of brilliant personalities in their respective fields, who consented to be members of EC on request from the earlier govt for their emotional attachment to this premier seat of learning.They'll definitely feel insulted and humiliated.

Not in jest!

(1)Political Rally!
Son:Dad, High court has summoned a political party for bringing school children to participate in their rally.
Dad: I know, my son.
Son: Why has court intervened in this matter,dad?
Dad: Because child lifting is a criminal offence, my boy.

(2)Teesta treaty!
Son: PM claims Didi was consulted in Teesta water sharing issue till the last moment.So Didi could have cancelled her visit earlier.
Dad: PM is right my, son.
Son: Then, Didi must be wrong, dad.
Dad: No, my son.Didi's is correct too.
Son: How,dad?
Dad: It's simple, my son.PM made the controversial change in the draft at the last moment.

(3) Terrorists' attack!
Son: Our lives are at the mercy of the terrorists, dad.
Dad: No, my boy.We rather mercy the terrorists.
Son: How dad?
Dad: Because we allow them to effortlessly strike us and escape unscathed in most cases.

7/9 Delhi High Court Blast!

Delhi high court blast is the same story of administrative callousness.This time ,of course, security lapses are unpardonable and unbelievable too.It was only on May 25 this year Delhi high court experienced a blast at one of its entrances.It was a stroke of good luck that the blast was of low intensity.It was an abortive attempt on the part of the terrorists to engineer a high intensity blast.But nevertheless no security measures were adopted since then though it was planned to do so.Administrative bungling reportedly stood in the way of installation of even CC TVs at the court premises, a minimum requirement for security measure.That apart, metal detectors too were non functional.It's alleged there was a broad based intelligence report of possible terrorists' attack at Delhi and there was no specific information.Now the blame game would start as usual and enquiry would be initiated with a slim chance of tracking down the miscreants.Even if the culprits are apprehended, would we get back the lives of the victims?Imagine how many families would be ruined.Delhi people still complain even in the wake of such a tragedy administration is yet to react properly.A sense of insecurity has engulfed them.Red alert has been promulgated in other metro cities also.But in reality we notice no extra security measures worth the name in Kolkata.Perhaps,situation is no better at other metros also.So far as security is concerned we've resigned to our fate.Now we know we'll live so long as the terrorists will allow us to.Since the twin tower tragedy in America not a single incidence of terrorist activity has ever taken place.Admittedly,in a poor and largely populated country like ours, we can't afford high tech security measures like America but we can't even do what we're capable of doing.People here are so attuned to such tragedies like terrorists' attacks, they take them in their stride and forget these incidents in a few days, of course except those who've lost their near and dear ones or survived this tragedy and remain maimed for life.

Teesta Water Treaty

Mamata's refusal
Last minute refusal of Mamata Banerjee to accompany PM, Dr. Monmohan Singh to Bangladesh to sign Teesta water treaty, among other things. baffled many.Only the other day Mamata was quite enthusiastic about her visit to Bangladesh with PM but she revised her decision at the eleventh hour.Mamata has alleged final draft of the water treaty is radically different from the earlier one that was brought to her knowledge.In the earlier draft Bangladesh was to get 25% of Teesta water which she agreed to but in final draft it was changed to 50%,which would jeopardise the interest of our state. What's more,the change was brought in without taking her into confidence. But why did center make this major change in the final draft without informing Mamata? Did it take Mamata for granted as her party is an ally of UPA-II govt?Or was it a benevolent gesture from a big brother to a small neighbouring state?Left too claim they had reservation against Teesta water treaty.In that case, center should have proceeded more cautiously posting Mamata on any major modification incorporated in the final draft.If the treaty is prejudicial to the interest of our state people would hold Mamata responsible for it and she'd would be poltically on the back foot.Decision to abandon a long awaited and much sought-after treaty at the last moment would not send a good message to the international community.PMO is responsible for inept handling of the situation.Unfortunate, indeed.
Dr.Ujjal.K.Pal,

An unfortunate decision!

Enquiry into Susanta Ghose's 'overstay' in hospital:
Govt's decision to form a three-man committee headed by the departmental head of Cardiology, R.G.Kar medical college, Kolkata to enqurire if Susanta Ghosh,former minister of Left Front govt now accused in Garbeta Skeleton case was retained in SSKM hospital by doctors for more days than required to examine his health when he complained of physical indisposition during interrogation in CID custody is unfortunate.Perhaps never before in our state, such a thing has ever happened.Govt suspects Mr. Ghosh was intentionally allowed to over stay in the hospital to avoid or delay CID interrogation.But it's not understood why doctors would unnecessarily detain Ghosh in the hospital in the name of medical examination.Do the govt think it's politically motivated and the team of doctors who examined Susanta belonged to a particular political party?In fact, such a decision would send a wrong signal to the medical fraternity.More over, it's unlikely that the doctors manning the enquiry committee would submit any adverse report against their colleagues
--

Free-for-all admission to pvt enggn colleges!!

It'd prove judicious if govt backtrack on its decision of admission of students who're poor rank holders in WBJEE and even those who've simply passed XIISc with minimum 45% each in Physics, Chemistry and Mathematics to elite institutions like Besu and J.U as well.Such a decision is unthinkable to the academic circle, let alone to the authorities of the two premier institutes of engineering education in our state.As expected, they've refused to compromise with merit and requested the govt to reconsider its decision.They're, however, unwilling to go in collision course with govt.

For private engineering colleges, however, the case is altogether different.Seats are lying vacant in many colleges and it inflicts financial loss on the owners of these colleges.So quite normally they'd try to fill up these seats by any means even by giving a go-by to merit.Govt has come to their rescue and lowered the norms of admission even to the XIIsc pass level.Money permitting even the most ordinary students who're not even fit for studying pass course in general stream would be admitted to these colleges.and might find it difficult to continue and ultimately drop out.Nevertheless those who'd be able to carry on are unlikely to finish with good results.Certainly, there are exceptions.WBJEE is a one day game where many good students fared badly.Similar is the case with XII exams or any examination in general.However,exceptions don't prove the rule.That apart. those who recruit engineers also consider the performance of the candidates in board examinations too.What's more to study engineering in private colleges is pretty costly now.Some take education loans.But after managing to have passed engineering exams some how if these ordinary students who are referred to here can't afford to have a job,will not they suffer from frustrations? Our private engineering colleges would also earn bad name.So govt should reconsider its decision of almost free-for-all admission rule for private engineering colleges in the interest of education and also for reputation of our state.

Compliments to Prakas Bajaj&Aranab Goswami

Prakash Bajaj,
Editor,
Times Of India,Bombay.

Thank you a lot for your sincerest active support to Anna's crusade against corruptions.No words are sufficient to praise your efforts to mobilise public opinion for this noble cause through your sustained campaign.Your social commitments and concern for social malaise should deserve praise from all those who like to see corruptions minimised in India.

The way you've boldly lashed out at corruptions of the politicians by name in your open letter to the Prime minister is unbelievable.You've not spared even the Prez of India.Really very few editors have the courage and conviction to do so.I once again thank you specially for this brave job.

I would fail in my duty if I skip, on behalf of all well meaning people, to extend thanks to Arnab Goswami of Times Now, a TV channel belonging to Times of India(if I'm not wrong) for successfully making people identifying with Anna's war against corruptions by his electrifying anchoring skill that was surcharged with rare combination of emotion and logic at the same time.
Wish you best of luck.
With Regards,

Dr.U.K.Pal,
Kolkata

Anna drama-a historical moment!

Anna drama ends with a happy note punctuated with some tense moments.Anna's triumph is people's triumph.Govt's reaction to Anna's demand for a stronger and effective Lokpal Bill was initially very rigid.It stuck to its own version of the Bill.Anna threatened to go on indefinite fast.Govt had an experience of Anna's earlier fast and the unprecedented mass support it enlisted.But it couldn't dare to foil Anna's fast the way it put an end to Baba Ramdev's movement against black money by midnight swoop either.So it tried to beat Anna before Anna could beat it. Govt put Anna behind the bar even before he could start his fast.Little did it think that Anna could start fast even in jail.Yes, he did and refused to leave jail unless he was permitted to fast in Ramlila ground.Govt conceded to Anna's demand.Then parliament was in session and govt had to face the opposition .On the other hand people started pouring in Ramlila ground from across the country.As days rolled on support to Anna grew tremendously.Entire nation seemed to have rallied behind him.Govt was put on the spot.It'd to suffer twin pressures-one from Anna team another from the opposition. Bouts of negotiations continued among Anna team,govt and the opposition.Now the problem boiled down to incorporation of three points in the Bill namely inclusion of lower bureaucracy,formation of Lokayuta in the state and introduction of Citizen charter.Anna claimed if these three points in Anna's Lokpal Bill were not accepted by the parliament he would not break his fast. Talk continued .Some times it seemingly resulted in break-through and sometimes in break-down.Oscillation between hope and despair breath takingly continued.At last parliament accepted Anna's three sticking points on the 11th day of his fast.Anna broke his fast on the 12th day.He said only half the battle was won.Whole nation watched the drama with bated breath.

Besu and J.U too!

Lowering the standard of Enggn education:
State govt's insistence on premier institutes like Besu and JU to admit candidates who've got lower ranks in WBJEE is really deplorable and unthinkable too.These institutes are well known for their excellence in Engineering educations and are normally first choices for very high rank holders in WBJEE.For campus violence, of course,BESU has, of late, earned bad reputation.But in academic excellence it still stands out as one of the best institutes in the country.To admit poor ranking students in these institutes just to fill up some empty seats in mechanical and civil engineering is a copromise on their standard and it merits no justification on any count.It's a long standing process for an institution to attain a high standard and it's all the more difficult to sustain it.For an academy to maintain its reputation it essentially needs good students apart from a good faculty.Govt should desist from imposing this unjust decision on these institutes particularly when it's put its best foot forward to make Presidency University a world class one.Incidentally,mentors of Presidency university have called such a move of the education department is quite unjust.

For private engineering colleges too govt's decision to fill up the vacant seats, if needed, even by students who passed class XII Sc with mere 45% marks each in Physics,Chemistry and Mathematics is also utterly unfortunate and impractical .Such a move is probably made with a view to making good the financial loss incurred by the corporates who own these colleges for quite a large number of seats are still falling vacant even after the counseling is over.Except a few private Eng colleges in our state most private colleges are yet to reach the desired level in terms of faculties and infrastructure.Now if no holds barred system is allowed for admission to such colleges, what message does it send to the corporate world that recruits engineering graduates?.
--

Banning Bandh

To Editor, TOI
Dear sir,
I beg to differ from Times view (25 August) that bandhs be banned.Nor do I think bandh be called at the drop of a hat as once Didi herself did.Bandh is a democratic tool of protest that should be used as a last resort.Fortunately, there're now fewer bandhs in our state.No political party except TMC would support the move to make bandhs illegal.However,I fully share your view regarding road blockade, rallies etc. in the city.

What's very interesting is once Didi called bandhs on flimsy grounds and now when in power she's campaigning for banning bandhs.It's still remembered how her supporters blocked a busy and very important high way like Durgapur Express Way for days together(15days) totally throwing traffic movement out of the gear during her Singur stir.It's also fresh in people's memory how her MLAs went on the rampage at Assembly house and ruthlessly broke furniture and other properties of the house.However,it's heartening that at last good sense has dawned on her

On Arundhati Roy's comments on Anna Hazare

Arundhati Roy has said nothing new.She's only echoed what the govt is saying.Does she think Lokpal Bill that govt has approved could be capable of combating corruptions?Since Independence we've seen umpteen instances of scams.But how many of scamsters have been punished?Perhaps not many or none.Immediately after India won freedom one of our national leaders assured us that black marketeers would be hanged at the lamp posts.But so far how many of such people have been awarded punishment by our law enforcing authorities?Definitely the number is too small to mention.In fact, the corrupt people have a free run in our society and common people watch it helplessly.Lokpal Bill that was conceived in 1969 languished in parliament for last 43 years.Corruptions have been way of our life and for those in high places they are mind boggling.Sad to say, many of our elected representatives who're in the corridor of power are abjectly corrupt.Raja and Kalmadi are just tip of the iceberg.When we, common people, resigned to fate that perhaps our country was destined to be one of the most corrupt countries of the world ,it's Anna Hazare who came like a god send and launched his movement against corruptions through his fast unto death.It gave a jolt to the govt and a knee jerk efforts were made to draft Lokpal Bill.Then where was social activist Arundhati Ray?It's easy to criticise Anna's movement and try to vilify his honest effort.Mind it's for nothing almost the entire nation has rallied behind him for a strong Lokpal Bill.These people are no fools as you think them to be.It's Govt Bill that is intended to pamper and perpetuate corruptions.Do you support this Bill simply because it has been approved of by our people;s representatives.Have you ever thought why people have lost faith in our elected representatives and reposed confidence in Anna whom you might criticise as extra constitutional center of power?Because our representatives have betrayed us and let us down.Unfortunately, nevertheless they enjoy the patronage of people like you in the name of supremacy of parliamentary democracy.Really sad!

Escape Route!

Lokpal Bill
Anna Hazare's fast falls on the 6th day today.Anna looks quite steady and cheerful. Effect of fast seems not to have yet touched Anna.Many others who're fasting with him have fallen ill and are suffering from dehydration.Anna is physically no superman but his extraordinary determination and power of will keeps him going.Nevertheless with days rolling on fast would take its toll and the septuagenarian might fall ill.Though initially the Gandhian leader was on indefinite fast but later he's declared he is on fast unto death.His fast would continue till his Jan Lokpal Bill is accepted by the govt.However, govt is yet to bend perhaps waiting for Anna to fall ill so that he could be removed to hospital.It is thought absence of Anna would dampen the spirit of the crowd who'll gradually thin out.But by all indications it's not going to happen and rather the opposite might happen with more people pouring in the capital to see Anna at hospital.Then it would be a trying time for Delhi administration to control the crowd which could turn violent.It's the electrifying presence of Anna that has restrained the crowd and no untoward incident has not so far taken place despite the presence of unprecedented mobilization of people.

What's unfortunate is the mood of the govt is one of confrontation and it's unwilling to open dialogue with Anna team though the latter has offered to sort out the matter through negotiation.Govt is rather unwilling to pay any special weightage to Anna as it argues Lokpal Bill as approved by the cabinet is now its property.It seeks people's opinion on the Bill by giving ad of the bill in print media and has decided to discuss the Bill only in the Standing Committee.What now govt tries to bring home to all is that there's no practically any difference between Anna and ordinary people of the country.They weigh equally the opinion of the civil society and that of common men.However, govt at heart knows it's consciously ignoring the ground realities and is at the receiving end in view of of the overwhelming support Anna is receiving from all sections of people.Now govt in fact tries to bail out of the present situation honourably and is groping for an escape route.Now the best option for the govt is to get the Lokpal Bill modified by the Standing Committee in the light of Anna's suggestions and passed in parliament.Hopefully, political parties wouldn't object to the provisions of the Bill in parliament considering the popular mood of the country.

State's name

After much fanfare West Bengal is renamed Paschimbanga.It's helped the state to ascend only a few steps in alphabetical ladder.Only for this marginal gain the hassles of changing the name of the state should not have taken.In fact, the name Paschimbanga is irrelevant as there's no Purbabanga now, only Banga could have been chosen.In that case in alphabetical order it could go much higher up.Even simple Bangla couldn't be a mean choice.It's no excuse that Bangla would be confused with our neighbouring state Bangladesh.Again,Bengal could be another option.If our country is called India and Bharat,why not our state be called Bangla and Bengal?I think Pachimbanga is rather an inferior choice to other names mentioned above, so a second thought may be given to the matter by the appropriate authority.

Anna's Fast

Govt has ultimately bent down.They've permitted Anna Hazare to go on fast for fifteen days at Ramlila Maidan ,Delhi. Anna would start indefinite fast today and not fast unto death as was his program on earlier occasion.It means he'd continue fast as long as his health would permit.This decision is communicated to press and public by Kiran Bedi, a member of Anna's team.

Interestingly,Anna is capable of continuing fast for nine consecutive days without any serious health problem, a social activist doctor closely associated with Anna claims.Incidentally,Anna is a patient of high blood pressure and takes anti hypertensive medicine regularly.That apart,he's a patient of peptic ulcer too.Still so enormous is his mental strength he'd manage to continue fast for days together putting govt on the spot.

However,a section of people in UPA govt think otherwise.They expect at this age Anna would not be able to continue fast for long as he'll fall ill and be hospitalized.When Anna will be in hospital, his supporters will thin out and as a result Anna's movement will lose momentum and might ultimately die down.

Perhaps those who indulge in harbouring above facile optimism are in fools' paradise.Popular discontent against corruptions is so intense and support to Anna is so spontaneous and overwhelming this anti-corruption stir will not tone down until parliament passes a strong Lokpal Bill to arrest corruptions.

What's most shocking is some people have started vilification campaign against Anna.They question Anna's honesty and integrity.Some even smell foreign hand behind the present movement.However, the Gandhian leader is made of sterner stuff.Nothing can stand in the way of his mission.

In view of the prevailing unrelenting popular mood against corruptions govt should shun its ego that whatever be the suggestions of Anna and the civil society regarding Lokpal Bill it's the parliament which would decide the final form of the Bill, no matter the legislation is not strong enough to take on corruptions effectively.The present unrest should not be allowed drift any more and it's high time govt could reach a compromise formula through dialogue with Anna and his team so that parliament can pass a strong Lokpal Bill as desired by millions of people of our country.

In lighter vein only!

On anti-corruption movement:

(1)Mayawati joins Anna's movement!
Son:Dad, Mayawati has extended support to Anna Hazare for his crusade against corruption.
Dad:I think Lalu prasad too would soon follow suit.
Son:May be, dad.
Dad:It's high time Anna could revise his decision of continuing fast.

(2)UPA on tiger's back!
Son: They say Anna's put UPA govt on a tiger's back making it difficult to alight by refusing to leave Tihar Jail.
Dad; But govt is behaving like a tiger still roaring against Anna's demand of Jana Lokpal Bill.
Son: If so, it reminds one of Bikram-Aur-Betal.

(3)USA behind anti-corruption movement
Son:Dad, UPA claims America is behind Anna's movement against Corruptions
Dad:Then we should be grateful to USA in helping us fighting corruptions.

--

Message on 65th Independencen Day

Have my heartiest greetings on the 65th Independence Day of our nation.Many of you've not seen the British Raj but fortunately or unfortunately I did.I can proudly claim I happened to be a witness to historic event of transfer of power from the British and emergence of an independent and sovereign nation India.On this auspicious day I can't help striking a discordant note like our Prime Minister that India has earned the dubious distinction of emerging as one of the most corrupt countries of the world in 65 years also.What's most worrying is our elected leaders fail or don't like to realize this home truth.So they're reluctant to weed out corruptions and instead endeavour to pamper them.It's people who can bring them to senses.Perhaps those days are not far off.We have to find solace in such optimism,may it be a wishful thinking.Thank you.

Proposed Agitation Against Lokpal Bill

It's shocking after passing a toothless and spineless Lokpal Bill that is to all appearances intend to perpetuate corruptions instead of eradicating them some of the high profile cabinet ministers vociferously demand any law passed by the parliament can't be objected to or adversely criticized by the civil society or any attempt to go in for agitation to modify the law in favour of their demand is an affront to parliament.Whatever is passed in parliament is not sacrosanct and so to contest it is no sacrilege either.The argument put forward by our elected leaders are not only silly but it's an attempt to take people for a ride. We have elected some people to parliament by electoral process who're entrusted with the power to pass legislations.It's expected they'd frame the appropriate law to suit the purpose and make no mistake deliberately or otherwise to serve some vested interest.So in case the law is found wanting in merit to tackle the situation people has every right to protest against such an impotent law as in case of Lokpal Bill.Delhi administration should in no way prevent Anna Hazare and civil society from launching agitation against Lokpal Bill.

Presidency University:Mentor group vs Council

Perhaps every institution has teething trouble when it starts functioning.So Presidency university might not be an exception.There has arisen a difference of opinion between the Presidency Council and the mentor group over opening of new courses at post graduate level though both members of the council and mentors are trying hard to make Presidency university as one of the best universities of the country by redeeming the lost glory.True, Presidency authorities have already taken decision to open PG courses in six new subjects like mathematics, statistics, history, political science, sociology and philosophy.But the decision can be reconsidered in view of the mentors' suggestion not to launch these courses because of lack of infrastructure.Though mentor group is only an advisory body and its suggestion is no binding on the council, it does not augur well for the new born university to respect the mentors more in defiance than in observance from the very beginning.Nor does it send a good message to people at large.It's expected the council and the mentor group would work in tandem.What 's worrying again Prof.Suranjan Das, vice- chancellor of Calcutta University who is member of the Presidency Council has contested the decision of the Council to open new courses at Post graduate level.It sadly reflects lack of coordination even among the members of the Executive Council.Any way, a spirit of confrontation between the members of the council and those of mentor group is extremely unfortunate and if it continues as such, the purpose of forming the mentor group to aid and advise the executive council for better functioning of the latter will be lost.So the problem should be sorted out as early as possible in the interest of the university.Other wise, it would only bear out the old saying:too many cooks spoil the broth.

Derailed Railways

Indian Railways are now in complete mess.It seems there's no administration worth the name to look after such massive network like Railways.Rail carries millions of people and is considered the main life line of our country.Rail is also the largest employer in public sector.What's very alarming is the safety and security of Railways are at the receiving end and so Rail is plagued with frequent accidents People now fear to board trains.Those who're on long journey by trains remain worried all the way and thank providence when they reach their destination safely. In fact, no body can assure a passenger that he/she would travel safe and reach the destination.What's very worrying again is more often that not faults in railway tracks are found to be root cause of accidents as they're not well maintained.In the recent derailment and head on collision between Guwahati-B'lore and Azimganj-Malda Passenger near Malda soil below the railway track was found to have subsided due to rains.It was not earlier detected for sheer lack of supervision.

Again, railway men sometimes badly lack their sense of responsibility.In the accident referred to above the guard of Guwahati express who remained unhurt after the accident didn't allegedly care to inform the station master of the nearest station with the help of his walkie talkie so that he(station master) could halt Azimganj Passenger there.Or he could show the in-coming Azimganj Passenger red signal from his lantern.In fact, he did none of the two.What a callousness!

Most of the Railway accidents now occur because of human errors.In post accident rescue operation and other related crisis management activities Rail's performance is far from satisfactory. Introduction of large number of new trains without upgrading infrastructure to bear the burnt has made the matter worse and also contribute to frequent accidents.

Rail has decreased man power sufficiently and so there're fewer people to check tracks and railway equipments regularly or properly.What's unfortunate, Rail has failed to press into service the much talked about anti-collision devices as yet reportedly due to lack of fund.It's difficult to think Rail stakes people's lives for financial constraints.

Passenger amenities have also touched almost rock bottom.Quality of food served from Railways pantry cars are normally poor and some times inedible.What's more,incidences of passengers being roughed up by employees of pantry car services of mail or express trains are now almost daily occurrences.New Railway minister is expected to take proper initiative to address the problems and put the Railways on right track.

It's hammer and not humour!

An open letter to Mir regarding Mirakkel:
Dear Mir,
Though I admire your sense of humour and your consummate skill to anchor a program, I can’t stomach many of the humours dished out in your much hyped program Mirakkel .They’re more hammers than humours as their punch lines more often than not grievously punch the listeners-cum- viewers’ mind. If I’m not wrong your Mirakkel is primarily a family show.But many of the humours are so overtly bed-pan type that they cannot be viewed or listened to with children. Of course, you might well contest my sense of obscenity and it might trigger a never ending debate about what’s obscene and what’s not. You might call me puritan too. Anyway, I’m not going to delve into such a debate and simply speak my mind and for that matter my opinion as a viewer. In fact, what’s shocked me is many of your participants have penchant for presenting sex-oriented jokes, that too bordering on vulgarity. What’s more shocking you along with your judges greet the contestants with thunderous applause when such jokes are presented. However, nothing is unmixed good or bad in the world. Many of your contestants on the other hand really present brilliant and sometimes thought provoking jokes that can cheer up even the most depressed and melancholic personalities. Admittedly, it’s really difficult to prepare intelligent jokes but it doesn’t necessarily means the contestants would indulge in openly sex-related jokes and you would encourage them by deafening claps. Isn’t it unfortunate?

An impotent Lokpal Bill!

It has happened what we were afraid of.Govt has approved of long awaited Lokpal Bill.But the Bill is toothless,clawless an impotent one and it's purportedly conceived to perpetuate corruptions.Since 1969 the anti corruption bill(Lokpal) was revived in parliament as many as ten times in long 43 years but it couldn't see the light of the day. So after inordinately long wait our parliament would deliver us a weak crippled and maimed Lokpal baby(Bill).If people don't vehemently oppose the approved Bill in the present form that would soon be placed in Parliament and to all probabilities easily passed dashing all our hopes to have a very powerful and all-encompassing Lokpal Bill that would effectively take on corruptions in every sphere of life and ours would be the least corrupt country of the world would be dashed to the ground.

Govt officers in the A grade and above are placed in the purview of the Bill though corruptions are found to amply pervade the lower rungs too.So unless a comprehensive approach is made to eradicate corruptions among govt officials the Bill is unlikely to produce desired effect.CBI has been left out of Lokpal and it's an open secret people in high places in govt are apt to influence CBI.It's under duress CBI has recently charge sheeted two union ministers who're now behind the bar.It's looked upon as more an exception than a rule.PM and higher judiciary are not placed in the ambit of Lokpal Bill despite strong and repeated suggestion by the members of the Civil society and innumerable people of our country.Even MPs' accountability to Lokpal for their corrupt activities in parliament like cash for vote etc. has not been conceded to.What's more, govt is trying to gag the dissenting voice regarding the Bill.Anna Hazare who initiated movement against corruptions through his fast unto death that gave a jolt to the union govt which was virtually caught napping over Lokpal Bill has now been denied permission by the adminitration to observe indefinite fast at Delhi in protest against the toothless Lokpal Bill.In fact, most of the important and valued suggestions of Anna's civil society have been honoured more in nonchalant defiance than in acceptance by the govt.

In jest only!

(1)Gorkhaland
Son: Dad, Center initially objected to the term Gorkhaland in the tripartite accord that has been signed but Didi convinced center that the term would do no harm. Why?
Dad: Because Gorkhas were unwilling to part with their land.

(2)Demand for statehood.
Son: Dad, Gorkha Janamukti Morcha (GJM) say they have not given up their demand for Gorkhaland as a separate state.
Dad: Similarly, Didi has not given up her demand for undivided Bengal, my son.

(3)Greater Coochbehar
Son: Dad, we all should support the demand for Greater Coochbehar.
Dad: Why my son?
Son: Then we’ll obviously get greater Bengal, dad.

Why in so hurry?

Mamata's fulfilling electoral promises:
Even the worst detractor of Mamata Banerjee would admit she's a woman gifted with inexhaustible treasure of energy and rare ability to work hard and fast too.She is an extraordinary personality ingrained with remarkable quality of taking drive and initiative whenever necessary.With in two months of her assuming office as Chief minister she's tried hard to fulfill many of her electoral promises.

What's interesting is she's always in a hurry and this hurriedness more often than not makes a mess of things.Immediately after taking oath as CM she attempted to make the treaty that LF govt made with Tatas on Singur Nano factory public.But due to legal hurdle she'd to back track.

To fulfill her electoral promise to return land from Singur Nano factory site to the 'unwilling' farmers she hurriedly made an ordinance.But she'd to hark back as the ordinance was later found to be unconstitutional by legal experts.So she hurriedly again passed a special legislation for return of the promised land in Singur in the assembly amid walk-out of the opposition.Later this legislation was contested in court of law by Tata Motors and is still subjudice.

Next to solve the problem of GJM who was long agitating at hills for separate Gorkhaland she made a Tripartite treaty between state govt, central govt and GJM on Gorkhaland Territorial Administration which has conferred maximum possible autonomy to GJM along with a portion of Dooars and Terai to be added to their territory.GJM is happy with this treaty particularly for inclusion of name Gorkhaland which paves the way for future movement for statehood.Not only that, the treaty itself categorically mentions GJM is not parting with their demand for separate Gorkhaland.In fact GJM leadership is making no bones about their demand for separate statehood.It simply means division of Bengal can't be altogether ruled out in days to come.What's more, resentment is running high among the tribals and other ethnic groups in Dooars and Terai against the merging of their land with Gorkhaland territory.That apart,the treaty is a shot in the arm of the sponsors of movement for Greater Coochbehar, who have started indefinite fast at Delhi and Coochbehar in support of their demand.

To bring peace in Jungalmahal she visited the place and promised to begin developmental activities there shortly.She declared all tribals of Jungalmahal were entitled to BPL cards.However,Maoists have their persistent demand for withdrawal of joint forces and release of all prisoners.CM has called upon the Maoists to open dialogue with the govt,abjure violence and return to main stream of politics.So whether peace would return to Jungalmahal depends on how Maoists react to CM's overture of peace.However, political circles are not very optimistic in this regard.

What is important is Mamata Banerjee's claim yesterday during her speech at victory celebration and observing martyr's day at Brigade Parade Ground that she solved all the above noted problems with in record time of two months has not yet proved true and we need to wait and watch for some time more for the results.

Hoax?

When LF govt, routed in assembly polls ,left writers’, coffer was reportedly empty. State’s now over head and ears in debt. However, Central govt has assured state to pay assistance to partially wriggle out of the financial crisis and advised it to earn revenue to strengthen economic position. But state govt fight sigh of taking measures to augment state’s income by levying taxes in some form or other lest it could be unpopular to public. Nevertheless it continues to make promises galore of developmental activities almost everywhere without caring for money to implement these developmental programs. The state has promised almost 70,000 new jobs in different spheres. Who will pay their salaries while state feel constrained to pay salaries of those who are already in service? Then are most of these promises made simply hoax? If so, isn’t it very unfortunate?

Paving way for statehood!

It’s not wise to believe Bimal Gurung’s statement(July 19) that GJM has not budged from their demand for separate Gorkhaland state almost with in 24 hrs of signing the tripartite treaty on GTA was made under duress to satisfy the sentiment of the hill people. It’s more so because in the treaty itself it has been put on record the GJM is not parting with their demand for separate statehood. The treaty has, in fact, officially accorded the right to GJM for movement for separate Gorkhaland perhaps in near future. In reality Mamata Banerjee has been able to purchase peace in hills in record time after assuming office. What’s interesting is a section of press has been almost hysteric about this treaty calling it ‘historic’. However, the word ‘Historic’ has lost its gloss due to frequent use. What’s certain our state is to be prepared to face a serious movement for separate Gorkhaland in days to come.

A Letter to Tara News

Dear sir,
I'm more or less a regular viewer of your News Paper Headlines program.I'm constrained to say your news analyst Mr. Ganguli, of late, analyses news so superficially and perfunctorily that it's unlikely to satisfy any serious viewer of your program.One certainly expects in depth analysis of a story from journalist of his stature and not the run of the mill interpretation.For example, today his discussion on tripartite treaty signed on GTA has been very commonplace and betrayed his lack of home work.More over, it was one sided and tinted with bias.He down played the story of Pratidin which said whenever CM was speaking of various developmental activities to be embarked upon for the hills,the body language of people at Pintail clearly indicated their ecstatic mood but when CM told Bengal would never be partitioned again their body language transformed into mellowed one.However; Mr. Ganguly could read the mind of GJM leaders when they categorically said the treaty did not mean they parted with their demand for separate Gorkhaland.According to Mr.Ganguly, they had to make such a statement out of political compulsion and as if it was not wise to read too much in such a statement.Nor did he dwell on the sentiment of the people particularly of tribals at Dooars and Terai vis-a-vis this tripartite agreement.


For sometime it's marked whenever comes the question of Lokpal Bill Mr.Ganguly spews venom on Anna Hazare and the members of the civil society for their insistence on inclusion of PM and higher judiciary in the Bill and Anna's threat to go on indefinite fast again if their demand is not conceded to,though they are not elected members.But what have our elected members so far done, Mr.Ganguly?They have simply pampered corruption in high places, if not try to perpetuate it.Isn't it a matter of shame on the part of our elected members that since 1969 Lokpal Bill was revived in parliament as many as 10 times in 42 years but it couldn't find the light of the day as yet. In the mean time corruptions have increased manifold and India has emerged as one of the most corrupt countries of the world.We should be rather grateful to Anna Hazare for initiating movement against corruption through his fast unto death.The way people have extended unstinted support to him in war against corruptions is unique and unprecedented and it's given a jolt to members of the govt who according to Ganguli are people's elected representatives.Admittedly,what's most unfortunate is we've had to lose confidence in our elected representatives.Now we repose all faith in Anna Hazare and his civil society, may be it's extra constitutional power of center.That apart,corruptions are so deep rooted and burgeoning by leaps and bounds we need a very effective and strong Lokpal Bill to contain them.It's believed only Anna Hazare and his civil society can forge it.

Tripartite Treaty on GTA

Shakespeare said,"What's in a name'?But, in fact, sometimes there's much in a name.Yes,I'm referring to Gorkhaland Territorial Administration(GTA).GJM has long been agitating for a separate Gorkhaland state.New govt under the leadership of Mamata Banerjee has not offered GJM a separate state named Gorkhaland but territorial autonomy under the name GTA.A tripartite treaty would be signed today in this regard.Perhaps nobody except state govt, central govt and GJM who're party to the treaty knows about its contents.Even the leader of the opposition is reportedly kept in the dark about what has been incorporated in the agreement.Naturally, though invited, he's not agreed to be present at the time of signing the treaty.However, he's dead against the word 'Gorkhaland' in the name of autonomous council(GTA).He's afraid the very name would pave the way to division of Bengal once more in future.A part of Terai region and Dooars would be included in Gokhaland Territory, hunt for which would be made by a 9-member committee.However, a section of people in these regions have started agitation against inclusion of their regions in the territory of Gorkhaland.

But why have GJM so happy over the treaty, though their main demand for separate state has not been concede to?So far it's known GTA has been given much greater autonomy than before.That apart they've been promised by the Central govt to pay Rs200.0 crores each year for developmental activities.. What's more, they see the name Gorkhaland as a stepping stone which would help them carry forward their movement of separate state more easily and logically too.In fact,their leaders have minced no words and categorically declared that they've not parted with their demand for separate Gorkhaland.

Transport Strike & New Govt

Whenever fuel price,particularly that of diesel, registers an hike substantially private transport operators start clamouring for fare rise.Initially govt flatly refuses to raise fare and the operators threatens to go on strike in return.Ultimately they resort to strike- first one day and then indefinite strike.However, they need not go on indefinite cease work as the govt in the mean time agrees to raise fare after negotiation with them.This drama is normally enacted in our state each time when fare is hiked following fuel price rise.Perhaps this time too in the regime of new govt there will be no exception.But caught in the crossfire of govt and private transport operators it is the commuters who suffer most.They' rather feel it's better to pay a bit higher fare than to be harassed by transport operators.The way rise of essential commodities takes place people have been made accustomed to pay higher price everyday.So rise in transport fare doesn't matter them much.They've been pushed to the wall and so have resigned to fate.
What's shocking is transport operators here never care for amenities of passengers.That ramshackle buses ply with passengers getting haplessly drenched in side the crowded bus is no uncommon scenario in Kolkata streets.So are the taxis which often greet the passengers with foul smell emanating from inside the vehicle.That apart taxi drivers here are very choosy.More often than not they decide which direction they like to go rather than the passengers.Taxi drivers' refusal is a chronic problem in the city and no serious and sustained efforts have ever been embarked upon by the administration to tackle this problem.Sometimes knee jerk attempts have been made without any result.This uncivilized practice of the taxi driver would continue even if fare is hiked even substantially.

New Education Policy

New education minister Bratya Basu has suggested some changes in school education.He's introduced English at primary level from class I, which is undoubtedly a welcome step.In addition he's made a novel but an extremely necessary move that teaching spoken English would be made compulsory at primary level.Some times despite knowing English well students can't communicate in English properly.Now a days in service or in practical life communicative skill becomes extremely necessary.More often than not students fail to qualify in interview for jobs because of lack of communicative skill in English.Perhaps this far no body will contest the move.But the implementation part of the move is not that easy.Where are the competent teachers at primary level in most of the academic institutions who would teach spoken English with proper pronunciation and accent particularly at districts, if not at Kolkata too?So the teachers should be first properly trained at renowned institutes of spoken English.So it'll take time to implement the new idea.

Minister's other suggestions might draw flak from most of the educationists.It's proposed that pass-fail system till class-VIII will be abolished.Nor there would be any unit tests till class VIII too.Half-yearly and annual examinations would be made optional.These moves, in fact,would do more harm than good to the education system.A student might make it to class IX practically without taking any examination.Isn't it absurd?

World Population Day

1)Birth right!
Son: Dad, as per 2011 census India's population is 1.21 billion,next to China.Why is population in India and China so high?
Dad:Because most of the people in the world prefer to be born in China and India, my son.

2)Man power!
Son:China has the highest man power in the world.
Dad:It's difficult to say, my boy.India may have higher man power than China.
Son: How dad? China has higher population than India.
Dad: May be, but man-woman ratio is much greater in India than China because of female foeticide,my boy.

3)Accommodative!
Son:Dad,India accounts for 2.4% of the world’s surface area yet it supports more than 17.5% of the world’s population.
Dad: It's simply because Indians are very accommodative in nature.

Engineering lowering of standard!

To fill up the vacant seats in private engineering colleges quality of engineering education is largely compromised. All India Council for Technical Education that is supposed to improve the standard of engineering education in our country becomes instrumental in degrading it simply because corporate houses that have invested crores of rupees for establishing engineering colleges are financially suffering for dearth of students.So eligibility for admission to engineering colleges has been made drastically low.A student can get him/herself admitted to engineering faculty even without appearing at JEE exams.Mere 45% marks in physics ,Chemistry and Maths in H.S exam are sufficient for one to seek admission to an engineering College.What's most ludicrous is initially this percentage of marks was fixed at 50% but still it failed to serve the purpose and so the percentage was further lowered.No body knows required marks might not be again decreased if seats still remain vacant in engineering colleges.Now the question is will different companies recruit these low grade engineers?Engineering education in private colleges has now been very much expensive.After spending so much of money if these students fail to secure jobs, will not they be extremely frustrated?

Crib deaths-more a social than a medical problem!

Following the crib deaths in B.C.Ray hospital our new CM has declared to establish another pediatric hospital in Kolkata.It's certainly a welcome move.But what's is more important is to ensure that ailing children could get proper treatment at rural health centers so that they don't get so critically ill that they need be rushed to Kolkata hospitals.Hence proper attention should be given to improve the infrastructure of rural health centers.Admittedly, it's easier said than done.In the first place in our country compared to patients, number of doctors is abjectly inadequate.That apart,doctors are,definitely not all, averse to going to work in village hospitals so that these health centers always run short of doctors.Sometime ago to address this chronic problem of dearth of qualified doctors in villages proposals were made to have specially qualified health service providers(less qualified than MBBS) for rural health services.Perhaps for some reason or other move could not materialise.What's most important is due to abject poverty mothers don't get any prenatal care in most of the cases in our country and more often than not they give birth to premature babies as our CM herself observed at B.C.Ray hospital during her visit.These babies are extremely under weight and chance of their survival after birth is quite poor.So crib deaths are more a social than a medical problem.True, medical negligence or non availability of medical facility might aggravate this problem but unless pecuniary condition of people improve crib deaths are unlikely to reduce.

Land Battle at Singur!

They say 'Justice hurried, justice burried' as well as "justice delayed,justice denied'.So it's advisable to follow moderate pace in this regard.But Mamata Banerjee is in unusual hurry, as if the time is running out, to fulfill the electoral promises of returning land to the 'unwilling' farmers of Singur.Return of acquired land to the land losers is admittedly a complicated legal process.Perhaps there is no precedence in this regard in the history of land deal in our country for public purposes.(Calcutta high court recognised making of Tat'a's Nano factory at Singur as public purpose).If Mamata Banerjee is ultimately successful in returning land to the 'unwilling' land losers at Singur negotiating legal hurdles, she would be acclaimed a pioneer in this respect.However,for this she primarily requires patience and every move is made with utmost care and caution.But she brooks no delay as her wont. and wishes to see the process complete almost over night.In fact, the more impatient she would be, the more likely for her to commit legal mistakes.

Though she herself claims 30days' notice is required prior to distributing land to the land losers, then why did she decide to return land to 12 'unwilling' farmers today as publicised in a large section of press?Of course,she herself in public and her lawyers in Supreme court have denied it but people know what's true.Did her men think Tatas won't get stay order on land distribution process so easily from SC and by this time land would be returned to the land losers.?If so,it was a facile optimism. In fact, such a hurry coupled with apparent trickery does not behove a govt that has come to power with massive mandate.

Press and Government

Now is going the honey moon period for the press with the new govt in the state. So the electronic as well the print media are vying with each other to show how more effusively one can eulogies the activities of the govt than the other. However, in doing so they are rendering more harm than good to the new govt. No doubt Mamata Banerjee in short span of time has brought home to people that he means only business. But she’s in a hurry as if she has not been elected for 5yrs term. So she's unnecessarily entangled herself in controversial issues that could have been attended to later on. Immediately after assuming office she tried to make the contract between Tatas and the Left front govt on Nano factory at Singur public. Due to legal hurdle she’d to back track. Again, for return of land to the 'unwilling' farmers of Singur she made an ordinance and that too faced rough weather because it proved to be unconstitutional and was almost forthwith abadoned.Then she passed Singur Bill in assembly in voice vote amid walk out of the opposition. The Bill was turned into law after it was signed by guv.As a fall out of these legislation farmers in other parts of the state have as expected started demanding return of their land too. What’s most serious is that Tatas have challenged this Singur legislation; it was of course a foregone conclusion, in the court of law. It’s likely the matter would roll down to the Supreme Court for final verdict and till then good-bye to return of land to the unwilling farmers of Singur.
True, TaTas are not in the good book of the present govt. for reasons known to all. Our new CM still refers TaTas as Tatababu rather sarcastically. But TaTas can’t be ignored as they’re now the biggest industrial house in the country. That apart if Tatas are treated so ignobly other players in the industry would think twice before investing in our state. All ready own-your-own-land policy for industries has perhaps made many players to turn their eyes away from our state. In fact, future of much-needed heavy industries that help in employment generation in a big way have become more or less bleak in our state. Instead of clapping all the time press should go in for constructive criticism whenever necessary and advise the govt in meaningful way. A critical press is much more desirable than a docile one to the govt which genuinely want to work for people.

--